Showing posts with label U-T. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U-T. Show all posts

Friday, August 19, 2011

San Diego Unified to review public records policy following complaint

Source: San Diego Union Tribune

Parent was originally told she would be charged for staff time to make copies

Written by: Ashly McGlone

A parent-activist who was going to be charged for staff time so she could see San Diego Unified Superintendent Bill Kowba’s calendar won’t incur that cost, after her story was highlighted in The Watchdog.

The district ended up charging Sally Smith $2.70 — 10 cents a page — for the cost of duplicating the public record.

Smith had been told she would be charged 10 cents per page "plus clerical time for the actual duplication, at a rate of $20 to $28 per hour."

Typically, public agencies charge for the cost of making a copy, not for staff time to do so.

After The Watchdog highlighted the effort to charge Smith for staff time, the district backed away.

The district’s policy of charging for staff time in such cases previously caught the attention of the Sacramento-based open-government group Californians Aware. That fee contributed to the district earning an F in the group’s audit of public agency compliance with public records law, released earlier this year.

District officials said they will now review their copying rates.

"We are entitled to recover the costs to produce a record that is maintained in electronic form," said Andra Donovan, the district’s deputy general counsel. She added, "In light of the concerns raised by the U-T, we will review our copying charges to make sure they are an accurate reflection of the direct costs of duplication."

Additionally, The Watchdog compared the calendar provided to Smith with a calendar provided to Emily Alpert of the Voice of San Diego and found that Smith’s calendar was incomplete and the redacting was inconsistent.

Alpert’s version included auditor visits, as well as cabinet, area superintendent and principal meetings, charity meetings, chamber of commerce and city events, select employee travel, sexual harassment training for a staff member, and media interviews — all of which were left off Smith’s calendar.

Meanwhile, Smith’s calendar included a carpool meet-up with the dean of San Diego State University’s College of Education and other employee travel redacted from the calendar provided to Alpert.

By law, agencies may withhold documents related to pending litigation and personnel, medical or similar files if disclosure would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy.

Told of the discrepancy, Donovan said the district will reproduce a more complete calendar and give it to Smith free of charge.

"We will also review our redaction policies to make sure we are consistently and appropriately redacting information," Donovan said.

Smith, who wished to compare Kowba’s appointments with those of former Superintendent Terry Grier, said she was concerned about the district’s handling of her request.

"Californians Aware graded school districts across the state and San Diego Unified got an F, and I can see why. It is intimidating to go in and ask for public records and have to encounter so much trouble getting them," Smith said. "San Diego Unified has to be more transparent and has to be open to requests and let the public see what it is doing."

In 2009, The San Diego Union-Tribune requested copies of the calendars for 55 local government leaders, including Grier. The requests were all fulfilled with no fees.

District officials said budget cuts no longer allow for such freebies.

MP3.com founder sues Del Mar school district

Source: San Diego Union Tribune

DEL MAR — Michael Robertson, the Internet entrepreneur who founded MP3.com in 1997, is suing the Del Mar Union School District for denying some of his recent requests under the California Public Records Act for internal emails.

Robertson, a Del Mar resident, filed the lawsuit in San Diego Superior Court on Aug. 8. Robertson’s two sons attended schools in the elementary school district, now with one in high school and the other finishing in June.

The lawsuit alleges that Del Mar Union wrongfully denied Robertson’s requests for all emails to and from Trustee Comischelle Rodriguez. According to court documents, the district has only released emails sent between Rodriguez and Superintendent James Peabody.

Robertson said he has made several request under the state’s open records law, which says any writing pertaining to the public’s business is public record, unless it is exempt, such as personnel evaluations.

Peabody, the district’s superintendent, said he could not comment on a pending lawsuit.

Robertson said he originally decided to pursue the emails to learn how the district spends taxpayer money. He said he became upset earlier this year when parents began receiving automated-phone calls with Peabody’s voice about a grass-roots campaign on the state budget crisis. Robertson said the call came at 7 p.m. on a Sunday to the emergency contact number he gave the district. He complained to the administration, and found out Peabody read a script written by the teacher’s union.

Robertson, a UCSD graduate, gained international fame when he founded MP3.com, a platform for music sharing that grew to more than 750,000 streaming and downloadable songs from 250,000 artists. The company went public in 1999, raising $344 million.

The Recording Industry of America successfully sued MP3.com for copyright infringement. Robertson paid $150 million to five recording labels as part of a settlement. Vivendi then bought MP3.com for $372 million in 2001.

Friday, August 12, 2011

District seeks fee for viewing of calendar

Source: San Diego Union Tribune

Written by: Ashly McGlone

The San Diego Unified School District is seeking to impose a fee on a parent requesting to review the superintendent’s calendar.

Public records law says such documents can be inspected during business hours and a state attorney general’s report says no fee should be charged.

Sally Smith, a parent and vocal critic of the district, is seeking to review Superintendent Bill Kowba’s calendar from January to July 2011 in order to determine whether she wants copies of any pages.

The California Public Records Act states that, "Any reasonably segregable portion of a record shall be available for inspection by any person requesting the record after deletion of the portions that are exempted by law."

Agencies are allowed to charge for copies of public records. But the open records law "contains no provision for a charge to be imposed in connection with the mere inspection of records," according to a report issued by the California Attorney General’s Office in 2004.

In the case of Kowba’s calendar, school district attorneys said that the calendar is only kept electronically and, in that form, portions can’t be redacted. They say printed copies must be made in order to strike out information exempted from the open records law in order for Smith to review the information.

Smith was told she would have to pay for printing costs "plus clerical time for the actual duplication, at a rate of $20 to $28 per hour," according to an Aug. 1 email from Adel Epley, assistant to the district’s deputy general counsel.

Smith, who contacted The Watchdog about the issue, wrote in response, "I just want to look at it. I can’t be charged for reviewing records."

The school district’s attorneys stand by the anticipated charge, though it was unclear what the total cost would be as of Friday.

Peter Scheer, executive director of the First Amendment Coalition, said, "The better argument under the law is they can’t charge for that."

In 2009, The San Diego Union-Tribune requested copies of the calendars for various local government leaders, including Terry Grier, then-superintendent of San Diego Unified. That request was fulfilled with no redaction and no fee was charged.


More information:

Thursday, May 20, 2010

Peabody gets unanimous vote to lead Del Mar schools

Source: Union Tribune

By Bruce Lieberman, UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

DEL MAR — James Peabody is the new superintendent of the Del Mar Union School District.

The school board voted unanimously earlier this month to hire Peabody as the district’s permanent superintendent, a little more than a month after he was hired as interim superintendent to replace Sharon McClain. The board fired McClain on March 31 after she and trustees clashed over management issues.

Her ouster has drawn criticism of the board from parents and teachers, who have long said that trustees have micromanaged district business. The trustees have been largely silent on exactly why they decided to fire McClain. Trustees Katherine White, Annette Easton and Doug Perkins voted to terminate her contract, while Trustee Comischell Rodriguez voted against the ouster, and Trustee Steven McDowell abstained. McClain has vowed to sue the school district for wrongful termination, although as of this week she hasn’t done so.

Peabody is working part time as superintendent of the Julian Union High School District. He will work on a per diem basis in Del Mar until July 1, when he will come on board full time.

He will be paid $750 per day, up to 16 days per month, before July 1, according to an employment contract that trustees signed May 5. His annual salary beginning July 1 will be $180,000. He will receive 25 days of vacation annually, 24 days of sick leave annually, a monthly automobile allowance of $400 and $1,200 per month paid toward his state retirement — among other fringe benefits.

The term of his contract is two years.

Peabody was out of town to attend his son’s graduation from medical school and could not be reached. He has a 38-year career in public education. He has been a classroom teacher, track and cross-country coach, curriculum specialist, assistant principal, principal and assistant superintendent.

He has also served as a trustee for the Alpine Union School District, and he worked for the San Diego County Office of Education as the director of its regional system of district and school support.

Bruce Lieberman: (760) 476-8205; bruce.lieberman@uniontrib.com

Monday, April 26, 2010

Del Mar school board president steps down

Source: Union Tribune

DEL MAR — School board President Comischell Rodriguez announced Monday that she is resigning her post, saying in a written statement that trustees who backed the recent ouster of the superintendent have essentially marginalized her on the board.

Rodriguez voted against firing Superintendent Sharon McClain on March 31. Rodriguez accused one or more colleagues — she didn’t specify any trustees by name — of signing official board documents without authorization, of trying to exclude her from closed-session discussions, and of meeting with the district’s legal counsel without authorization.

Trustee Katherine White, who along with trustees Annette Easton and Doug Perkins voted to fire McClain, said Monday that no improprieties by any trustees have occurred. White acknowledged signing on April 7 a letter of intent to hire interim Superintendent James Peabody, but she said she had authorization to do so as a member of a board subcommittee, and Rodriguez was out of town at the time.

“I don’t see any action ... that has marginalized her,” White said.

White has said previously that the board had various complaints about McClain’s performance, among them that she didn’t communicate sufficiently with trustees. Board critics have argued that the board majority micromanages district affairs and made it impossible for administrators to do their jobs

More information:

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Parents plan to target trustees after superintendent’s ouster

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

Thursday, April 15, 2010 at 12:12 a.m.

DEL MAR — Two weeks after the Del Mar school board fired its superintendent, Sharon McClain, a group of parents told the trustees their days are numbered.

Compared with the outrage that preceded McClain’s ouster, Wednesday night’s protest at a board meeting seemed tame. Nevertheless, the dozen or so protesters said they are organizing to make sure the Del Mar Union School District board sees some big changes in the November elections.

On March 31, trustees Katherine White, Annette Easton and Doug Perkins voted to fire McClain at a specially scheduled board meeting held in the middle of a workday, when most parents and teachers were unable to attend.

Trustee President Comischell Rodriguez voted against firing McClain, and trustee Steven McDowell abstained. McDowell wouldn’t say why he declined to vote.

White, Easton and McDowell are up for re-election in November.

McClain has vowed to sue the school district, saying she was ousted for no reason. Because the trustees claimed that McClain had committed a “material breach” of her contract, they severed her contract and immediately ended salary payments and benefits.

Board members have refused to say anything about their decision, although for months McClain and the board had clashed over the superintendent’s management style.

Some trustees claimed that McClain did not keep them adequately informed on various school issues, a charge McClain strongly denied. Board critics have argued that trustees have tried to micromanage district affairs.

At last Thursday’s board meeting, a handful of speakers said the board had acted recklessly in firing McClain.

“You have taken an action fully knowing that you are burdening the district with an expensive lawsuit at a time when we are struggling with severe financial cutbacks,” parent Jill Steiner told the board Wednesday.

Parent Heidi Niehart said, “I would ask that four of you resign now, but if not, we will get rid of you in November.” She was referring to White, Easton, McDowell and Perkins. Perkins will not face re-election until 2012.

In February 2008, White, Easton and McDowell voted to oust Superintendent Tom Bishop after the three board members had clashed with him over management issues.

The trustees struck a deal with Bishop to make him leave, at a cost to the district of more than $300,000.

Six months later, the trustees announced their unanimous decision to hire McClain, then the superintendent of Hermosa Beach City School District.

James Peabody, who is serving part-time as superintendent at Julian Union High School District until a replacement can be found there, was appointed by the Del Mar board on April 1 to serve as interim superintendent. The school board is expected to vote on an employment contract with Peabody by the end of the month.

“I am more than delighted to be here, and to be of service to the community and the school board,” Peabody said in a statement last Thursday. “I am interested in helping to move the school district forward and aid (the school board) in selecting a new leader, when that point comes.”

Bruce Lieberman: (760) 476-8205; bruce.lieberman@uniontrib.com

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Parents speak out against firing of Del Mar schools chief

Source: San Diego Union Tribune

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

Wednesday, April 14, 2010 at 10:02 p.m.

DEL MAR — Two weeks after the Del Mar school board fired its superintendent, Sharon McClain, a group of parents told the trustees their days are numbered.

Compared with the outrage that preceded McClain’s ouster, Wednesday night’s protest at a board meeting seemed tame. Nevertheless, the dozen or so protesters said they are organizing to make sure the Del Mar Union School District board sees some big changes in the November elections.

On March 31, trustees Katherine White, Annette Easton and Doug Perkins voted to fire McClain at a specially scheduled board meeting held in the middle of a workday, when most parents and teachers were unable to attend.

Trustee President Comischell Rodriguez voted against firing McClain, and trustee Steven McDowell abstained. McDowell wouldn’t say why he declined to vote.

White, Easton and McDowell are up for re-election in November.

McClain has vowed to sue the school district, saying she was ousted for no reason. Because the trustees claimed that McClain had committed a “material breach” of her contract, they severed her contract and immediately ended salary payments and benefits.

Board members have refused to say anything about their decision, although for months McClain and the board had clashed over the superintendent’s management style.

Some trustees claimed that McClain did not keep them adequately informed on various school issues, a charge McClain strongly denied. Board critics have argued that trustees have tried to micromanage district affairs.

At last Thursday’s board meeting, a handful of speakers said the board had acted recklessly in firing McClain.

“You have taken an action fully knowing that you are burdening the district with an expensive lawsuit at a time when we are struggling with severe financial cutbacks,” parent Jill Steiner told the board Wednesday.

Parent Heidi Niehart said, “I would ask that four of you resign now, but if not, we will get rid of you in November.” She was referring to White, Easton, McDowell and Perkins. Perkins will not face re-election until 2012.

In February 2008, White, Easton and McDowell voted to oust Superintendent Tom Bishop after the three board members had clashed with him over management issues.

The trustees struck a deal with Bishop to make him leave, at a cost to the district of more than $300,000.

Six months later, the trustees announced their unanimous decision to hire McClain, then the superintendent of Hermosa Beach City School District.

James Peabody, who is serving part-time as superintendent at Julian Union High School District until a replacement can be found there, was appointed by the Del Mar board on April 1 to serve as interim superintendent. The school board is expected to vote on an employment contract with Peabody by the end of the month.

“I am more than delighted to be here, and to be of service to the community and the school board,” Peabody said in a statement last Thursday. “I am interested in helping to move the school district forward and aid (the school board) in selecting a new leader, when that point comes.”

Bruce Lieberman: (760) 476-8205; bruce.lieberman@uniontrib.com

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Del Mar board usually good for parting "gifts"

By Logan Jenkins
Source: Union-Tribune

Before flying off to Hawaii, Sharon McClain swore she’d sue.

See you in court, the fired superintendent of Del Mar Union School District said to her old bosses.

Given the school district’s gold-plated history, you can understand why the 65-year-old educator would feel poorly treated.

In 1998, Del Mar Superintendent Robert Harriman got sideways with his school board. He was summarily placed on administrative leave, a dramatic and mysterious move. A couple of months later, he was let go and rewarded with a going-away package worth $166,000.

Tellingly, no one, neither Harriman nor the board, fully revealed why he had been relieved of his duties and then forced out.

Silence, as everyone knows, is golden. And it usually costs some gold to secure it from fired employees with scores to settle.

Ten years later, Tom Bishop, Harriman’s successor, lost his normally sure footing. After ushering in a period of intense growth, Bishop made some archenemies over boundary changes and the controversial sale of school land in downtown Del Mar.

In 2006, a new wave of trustees telegraphed that they were going to take the imperious Bishop down a notch.

After an emotionally charged 2008 meeting in which Bishop loyalists vented their grief, the board forked over $300,000 in walking-away hush money.

In the termination chess game, the Bishop had not been rooked. He was a rich king headed into deluxe exile.

But as in Harriman’s case, the gentleman’s agreement, typically codified as a “nondisparagement clause,” ensured that none of the principals would say anything nasty about the other.

Having performed its bloody — and costly — work, the new board was free to hire the ideal superintendent, a custom fit for Del Mar’s new direction.

Oh, happy days!

---

After a professional head hunt, the board hired McClain in the summer of 2008, an Escondido music teacher who had worked her way up through the ranks to public education’s pinnacle — superintendent.

"She is a great match for this district because of her interests, because of her energy, because of her consensus building," board member Janet Lamborghini gushed. “I could go on and on.”

Sweet music to Del Mar’s freshly singed ears.

Fast forward to March 31, 2010. Eight days ago.

The board hurriedly called a daytime meeting to announce that McClain, as many had predicted for months, was getting the sack. The shocker was that McClain was being fired for cause, meaning that instead of a year’s salary, the amount she would receive if terminated without cause, she would get not one dime to hit the bricks.

The number of people who stood up to speak in opposition to the board and in favor of McClain? Roughly 30.

The number of people who stood up to speak in support of the board’s decision? A smooth zero.

By my unscientific polling, this board’s approval ratings have dropped below those enjoyed by Congress.

One of the witnesses at the packed auditorium at Del Mar Hills Academy was Peter Kaye, a seasoned journalist who lives in Del Mar.

“In 50 plus years as a reporter and editor,” Kaye e-mailed me, “I’ve covered everything from SDS to White Citizens’ Council meetings, but I’ve never seen such a sustained level of anger as I did last Wednesday. They made the Tea Party movement look like a tea party.”

---

So what happens now?

After her sojourn in Hawaii, McClain will have to take stock of her position on the legal chessboard.

Compared to McClain, the district has bottomless pockets, thanks to taxpayers. The board can afford to drag out litigation long beyond November, when a new board will likely take control of a public school system with an incredibly rich academic gene pool.

Presumably, the newly constituted board will have a very different view of McClain’s deficiencies, real or alleged.

If McClain files a lawsuit, one that probably will claim chronic mistreatment from a board majority for whom many believe the word micromanagement was coined, she might have to devote a couple years of her life to the crusade. In the end, attorney fees could swallow up any judgment.

On the other hand, McClain may find in the next board (if not the current one) willing negotiators in a quiet, reasonable settlement, say a third of her annual salary and a statement that she served the district capably under unusually trying circumstances. She gets her good name back — and some green hush money.

If she chooses, McClain can go public and sing a compelling blues number about how her bosses, they done her wrong.

But it’s unlikely that song will go gold in a courtroom.

Saturday, April 3, 2010

In brief ... / Both dumb and indefensible

In brief ... / Both dumb and indefensible

Source: Union Tribune

So the Del Mar school board has burned through another superintendent, at a likely cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars. Sharon McClain’s judgment is open to question, given her apparent attempts to rewrite her contract to spike her pension. But evidence suggests this is one more example of muscle-flexing in a small district by a bullying, micromanaging school board. Now this board is trying to use one of the tiredest tricks around to avoid explaining why it dumped McClain: claiming its hands are tied because of legal threats and state personnel privacy laws. Bunk. There is no law that says a school board can’t give its reasoning when making important personnel changes. Nor is this risky – at some point in legal proceedings, the board is going to have to explain its decision anyway. To refuse to do so now is both indefensibly secretive and dumb.


Note: Counsel for the Capistrano school board released a 54-page document detailing the reasons for termination of their superintendent at the same time he was fired.

More information:

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Del Mar schools chief out; legal war expected

Source: Union Tribune

DEL MAR — A divided Del Mar school board yesterday fired its district superintendent, Sharon McClain, setting the stage for a protracted legal battle that could cost the school district hundreds of thousands of dollars.

McClain, terminated by some of the same board members who hired her less than two years ago, vowed that she would fight her ouster in court. Because the board voted to fire her “with cause,” all pay and benefits cease immediately. The board said McClain had committed a “material breach” of her contract, but the trustees refused to say publicly what those violations were. They would not comment further, citing the threat of a lawsuit.

Trustee Katherine White, who for months had tried to build a case for firing McClain, has said the superintendent fell short on several performance measures, chief among them that she failed to keep the board informed on numerous matters. They included  hot-button issues such as potentially closing a school and finding space for a new district office, White has said.

But McClain always countered those claims, and at Wednesday’s meeting she reiterated previous statements that detailed the lengths to which she kept trustees up to date on school affairs.

“I’m going to leave, but they will hear from me,” McClain said moments after the vote. “I felt like I did a good job. … I don’t feel like I did anything I should be fired for.”

Yesterday morning before the meeting, McClain was more blunt. “I will sue them because this is not right,” she said.

White and trustees Annette Easton and Doug Perkins voted to fire McClain. Trustee Steven McDowell, who has typically sided with his three colleagues on most board matters, abstained. Board President Comischell Rodriguez voted against the dismissal.

In a brief statement, Rodriguez said, “After many months of trying to work with Superintendent McClain to resolve a number of serious and material performance violations of her contract, the board of trustees voted to terminate the district’s contract.” Rodriguez said the board wants to move in a “new direction” with a “renewed sense of focus.”

But more than 30 people who addressed the board before the vote said firing McClain was a reckless power play that will waste precious dollars at a time when the district is laying off dozens of teachers and cutting back programs.

Board critics have argued for years that White, Easton and McDowell — who formed a voting bloc after the school board election in November 2006 — have sincessantly micromanaged school district affairs and turned board meetings into marathon sessions that nitpick over minutiae.

White, Easton and McDowell all supported hiring McClain in the summer of 2008. The three trustees had ousted former Superintendent Tom Bishop that year in a settlement that has cost the district more than $300,000.

By firing McClain, the district could be liable for at least $500,000 in eventual payments to her, some speakers said at yesterday’s board meeting.

“I really think this is a matter of you not liking Dr. McClain for whatever reason — jealousy, a power struggle,” said Kate Takahashi, a district parent. “It’s a half-million-dollar hissy fit.”

The board has scheduled a meeting for 5 p.m. today to appoint an interim superintendent.


Reader comments:


gdeal 03/31/2010 05:07 PM

not cool.


Cydjim 03/31/2010 05:17 PM

If I lived in Del Mar, I would pay attention at next school board vote: last superintendent cost a half mil and so will this firing..a million bucks sure goes a long ways if spent right


DMUSDparent 03/31/2010 09:07 PM in reply to Cydjim

precisely our point. our board should be spending this money on programs and staff in a way that benefits the children that the district educates.


sdnative10 03/31/2010 05:37 PM

These school board members don't understand they should have spent their time establishing clear, consistent and practical policies for the superintendent to then implement and stayed out her way so she could do her job. Instead, the boardmembers seem to want to run the district themselves and usurp the superintendent.

If the boardmembers couldn't get along with either the previous superintendent or the one they hired themselves it should be obvious to everyone that the real problem has been with the board and not the superintendents. This firing is unjustified and could cost the district far more than the $300,000+ the district had to pay the last time.


encinitasresident2 03/31/2010 06:08 PM

Sounds like some key detials are missing. How do you get fired from a job now adays with out several written warnings and councelings? Was she on notice for violating any rules, laws, regulations, or agreements? Not liking somebody is not a good enough reason. Poor performance means what?..doesn't that require documentation. Hopefully the details will be made public sooner than later.


DMUSDparent 03/31/2010 09:08 PM in reply to encinitasresident2

there have been secret meetings to this effect for months, beginning in sept. but the community still cant get a straight answer as to "why?"


TomTheSeal 04/01/2010 09:30 AM in reply to DMUSDparent

That would be a great question for your school board members, but, you are not likely to get an answer and the reasons could be any number of things from pending litigation, it is a confidential personnel matter, to, quite simply, we do not have to answer that question.

It is far past the time when the school board system in America should be ditched and replaced with something that requires demonstrated competence, knowledge, experience, and PRIOR CERTIFICATION before someone can be a member of a team that leads and guides the education of our children.

Why require PRIOR CERTIFICATION for teachers and not for school board members ?

Doesn't make sense, and, obviously, school boards in CA, and nationwide actually, are demonstrating their incompetence, ineptness, and disastrous and costly malfeasance of duty.

Time to ditch the school board dinosaur.


windansea 03/31/2010 06:23 PM

In America when this happens, you receive millions of dollars in settlement. Even if you did a poor job, the vulture slime scum extortionist lawyers find a way to make them and you very wealthy. Sweeeeeeeeet !!!!!!


TomTheSeal 03/31/2010 08:16 PM in reply to windansea

Did she do a poor job ? Or has the school board done a poor job ?

We'll see, but, only thanks to some good lawyering. Reading your comment I sort of think that one day maybe you yourself might need a good lawyer to rescue you from your comments.

Be careful where you make them. Some do not take kindly to being smeared.

Even here, where you have SOME annonymity, you can be called to account in a court of law.

Regards,
Tom


windansea 04/01/2010 04:52 AM in reply to TomTheSeal

Hey Tom, why didn't the lawyer get eaten by sharks when he fell off the boat ?

Professional courtesy.


TomTheSeal 04/01/2010 08:20 AM in reply to windansea

Great joke ! A classic. Been around for awhile and, unlike Del Mar superintendents, has a great shelf life.

Why DIDN'T the CLIENT get eaten by sharks when HE fell off the boat ?

His lawyer was the best shark in the water and saved him.

Regards,
Tom


sandiegorain 04/01/2010 05:50 AM in reply to TomTheSeal

Groan


skeptic6 04/01/2010 11:04 AM in reply to TomTheSeal

Tom, sometimes you make me like lawyers again. ; )


FailObamaFail 03/31/2010 06:42 PM

They make HOW MUCH?!?!


Butkus 03/31/2010 06:58 PM in reply to FailObamaFail

That information is in the article.


writenow 03/31/2010 07:38 PM

Del Mar Superintendent's have long had a short, shelf life. But they do keep attorneys employed.


ImJustABill 03/31/2010 07:39 PM

"The school board’s vote followed a lengthy closed session, and trustees refused to talk about their decision, citing pending litigation."

This is a public school district spending public money. Litigation or not, the public has a right to know the reasons for this action.


ImJustABill 03/31/2010 07:41 PM

"McClain said she would fight the decision in court."

Translation: I want to squeeze every dime out of the taxpayers that I can.


TomTheSeal 03/31/2010 08:11 PM in reply to ImJustABill

Translation: Everyone is entitled to their day in court.

Translation: This particular school board has displayed a pattern of mismanagement and incompetence.


ImJustABill 04/01/2010 07:18 AM in reply to TomTheSeal

Sorry I disagree with the implication of the first comment.

Although, certainly you are correct that everyone does have a right to their day in court that doesn't mean I have to approve of their decision to use that right.

In my opinion, an employer has a right to fire an employee.

Unless there was something grossly wrong going on (e.g. sexual harrassment, physical threats, theft) an employee who sues their employer just because they were fired is a pathetic greedy whiner.


Cydjim 04/01/2010 08:08 AM in reply to ImJustABill

Luckily the majority and the law doesn't agree with your belief; if you make a contract with an employee that you pay for x and they do x then you pay for it. An employee forgoes other opportunities to work for that employer.

Another analogy, you agree to pay for a car. You decide you don't like it...in real world you still pay for it. In Del Mar case, they are looking hard for a reason to blame the other guy and if they can easily demonstrate it to 12 people then they are off the hook

Del mar is trying to void the deal the made, she is not suing for her. She is suing to make sure they give her what they promised, unless Del Mar board can find a valid reason which seems this case doesn't exist....so good luck


TomTheSeal 04/01/2010 08:12 AM in reply to ImJustABill

Bill, I agree ( "...an employee who sues their employer just because they were fired is a pathetic greedy whiner..."). However, the first comment remains valid because it is that day in court that sorts out the details and keeps us from settling our differences on our own, which can get pretty darned ugly.

As for an employer's RIGHT to fire an employee, I agree in principle, but that right is now bridled with some legally defined responsibilities ( You cant fire someone because they are Latino ).

Employers sometimes do egregious things and MOST of the time they get away with it. But every now and then they have to answer for something egregious that they have done.

It will be enlightening, to say the very least, as to what emerges at trial. We have a school board that has a responsibility to use taxpayer money wisely and the former superintendent had certain contractual, legal, and moral responsibilities herself. A trial, unless it becomes a sealed lawsuit, will hopefully reveal some behaviour that perhaps up until now has been kept from the taxpaying and parental public.

Have a good one Bill, as I know we are not going to agree on this. But that's ok.

Regards,
Tom


skeptic6 04/01/2010 10:49 AM in reply to ImJustABill

"In my opinion, an employer has a right to fire an employee."

I would agree with you, IF this were a company owned by the board. But it isn't. It's just school district, "owned" by the taxpayers, and the board should be representing their interest.


olc 04/01/2010 10:10 AM in reply to ImJustABill

"Translation: I want to squeeze every dime out of the taxpayers that I can."

Because these clowns have overstepped their authority and violated our contract. As for whose money it is, who elected them?


gkhi 04/01/2010 10:16 AM in reply to ImJustABill

The Board was fully aware that she would sue. It is her right; she is near retirement. She has children, grandchildren, foster children. Plus, it's her reputation. No one in their right mind would begrudge her for suing. And I'm sure she doesn't relish the thought of a lawsuit at this point in her life.


skeptic6 04/01/2010 10:47 AM in reply to ImJustABill

I don't blame her one bit, they didn't give a reason, well, not a valid reason, and they are sullying her reputation.


AhSo 03/31/2010 07:53 PM

can't wait for this to hit the court and I can read all the dirty laundry about the kooks running this school board. Hip, hip del mar.


SanDiego92129 03/31/2010 08:05 PM

"...McClain was fired for material breach of her contract..."

What does that mean? Hey UT -- start digging and try to become a respectable rag again.


TomTheSeal 03/31/2010 08:07 PM

The performance of CA school boards is, quite simply, abysmal.

The school board system should be ditched and replaced with something that requires knowledge, competence, experience, and PRIOR CERTIFICATION through rigorous testing.

With the school board system you need not know ANYTHING to guide our schools.

The ONLY THING being on the school board means is that you ran a successful campaign.

BFD


la_mesan8ive 03/31/2010 08:26 PM in reply to TomTheSeal

You're right Tom (you're not Tom Bishop, are you??)

School boards are a joke. They are filled with wanna be politicians and religious nut jobs with strong personal agendas that have absolutely nothing to do with providing children with the best education possible.

They are a place for self-employed people to get full medical and dental insurance for their families while only "working" a couple of hours a month.


TomTheSeal 03/31/2010 08:43 PM in reply to la_mesan8ive

If you are referring to the former Superintendant of the Del Mar Union School District who ostensibly was forced to step down and did so onn April 30, 2008, no I am not that Tom Bishop.

Bishop by majority opinion did a stellar job, but he developed a rocky relationship with the school board since late 2006, when trustees Katherine White and Steven McDowell joined Annette Easton to form a board majority.


DMUSDparent 03/31/2010 09:10 PM in reply to la_mesan8ive

if the DMUSD board gets medical and dental benefits, that would be news to me. as far as i am aware, they get a small annual stipend to cover the cost of insurance to protect them from lawsuits.

which they will now be grateful they have.


skeptic6 04/01/2010 10:45 AM in reply to la_mesan8ive

Oh, now you did it. : ) You dragged in the Grossmont School Board into this. But it's unlikely they will quarrel with their Superintendent, right?


dmsoccerfan 03/31/2010 08:33 PM

Even though the school board claims they FIRED MCLAIN FOR CAUSE, just wait a few months.

The school board will approve a six figure payout, using the justification that "it's cheaper to settle than to spend money on attorneys fighting the lawsuit".

As part of the settlement, there will be clauses of SILENCE on both sides, so the public will NEVER KNOW the reasons the school board used to justify the firing, and whether or not they were valid...........sort of like the Tom Bishop firing -- he got a payout, and no one knew if his firing was valid or not.


ImJustABill 04/01/2010 07:13 AM in reply to dmsoccerfan

I think the public's right to know what happened trumps any argument for staying quiet due to ongoing litigation.

The litigation could take years.


dmsoccerfan 03/31/2010 08:35 PM

......and what's up with McDowell "abstaining" from the vote? Could there be a conflict of interest coming along? This just doesn't make sense. Please, if anyone understands the McDowell action, please clarify?


DMUSDparent 03/31/2010 09:11 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

... he has no spine.


sandiegovoice 04/01/2010 12:24 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

I agree with the spineless comment....just like Bob McClellan on the El Cajon City Council. He is worthless. Sits on the council and abstains from every vote that is controversial. He always uses his ownership of his car dealership as an excuse that it could be conflict of interest.


DoneAgain 03/31/2010 08:51 PM

She was my music teacher in the 80s. I think there is real value in having an actual educator and especially one that educated in what is currently an "endangered" field in public education in charge. I will be interested to see how this plays out.


theryanexpress 03/31/2010 09:38 PM

Hey !! Wadya know. A job opening for Alan Bersin!


MMIKEY 04/01/2010 08:10 AM in reply to theryanexpress

he already screwed up the similar job a few years ago, and moved on to more incompetence in job performance


92106Native 03/31/2010 10:27 PM

So, how long before the citizens of the Del Mar Union School District fire the Board?


sd68native 04/01/2010 03:49 PM in reply to 92106Native

November....


Augustus 04/01/2010 07:37 AM

Don't you love it when these public employees hire each other, fire each other, then sue each other ... and the taxpayers get to pick up the dime?


MyView 04/01/2010 07:43 AM

And who would want to step up to take this position now after seeing the temperment of this board? Maybe Katherine White should try it for awhile....


MMIKEY 04/01/2010 08:11 AM

any of the board members have their kids in school now?


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 12:59 PM in reply to MMIKEY

i think katherine white might have one left in elem school (interestingly, the school that McClain just recommended be reconfigured.... hmmmm)


GeraldR5 04/01/2010 08:21 AM

One of the biggest problems in education today is school boards. These people are elected to oversee a district, but they envision themselves superintendents or assistant superintedets who delve into every aspect of school district operations annd meddle in daily minutia. They end up harming the district far more than just "oversight." A dear friend of mine who was once superintendent of the largest district in the South Bay told me in private, "If it weren't for unfunded state mandates and pet programs of board members, I could reduce the district budget by 40 percent without losing a teacher or classroom and give each teacher a reasonable raise." Moreover, school boards are increasingly elected primarily by special interest groups who they bow to from the first to the last day of their terms! No wonder we have so much trouble retaining decent superintendents,.


TomTheSeal 04/01/2010 09:04 AM in reply to GeraldR5

GeraldR5, you wrote, "...school boards are increasingly elected primarily by special interest groups who they bow to from the first to the last day of their terms! No wonder we have so much trouble retaining decent superintendents...

" MY COMMENT: Amen, brother ! Amen. School board members are bought and paid for and push agendas that have absoulutely NOTHING whatsoever to do with the effective and efficient OVERSIGHT ( not management, please ) of the school system. School board members often know NOTHING about school systems or how they should work, not to mention having no knowledge, experience, or competence in the educational process.

THE *** ONE *** COMMONALITY FOR *** ALL *** SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS ? They ran a successful campaign for the position, and that's not saying much, is it ?

Time to free our schools of this anchor around both the necks of taxpayers, children, parents, teachers, administrators, and support staff. Time to ditch the school board system in America.


zeke199 04/01/2010 01:15 PM in reply to GeraldR5

Judging from the numbers I'd say your friend was spot on. "Fair Share" is one state mandate killing DMUSD and other districts which were in good shape before this socialist legislation was thrust upon us.

A voucher initiative is the best thing that could happen for our kids and our future! Let underperforming districts feel the pain so they must adapt or die. It works for colleges and universities so it will work for primary/secondary schools too. It may hurt in the short term but will make everyone stronger in the long term! How else can private schools continue to attract kids during this economic downturn?

Until the people wisen up and demand vouchers happen we're wasting time polishing chairs as they slide down the deck of the Titanic.


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 03:27 PM in reply to GeraldR5

""If it weren't for unfunded state mandates and pet programs of board members, I could reduce the district budget by 40 percent without losing a teacher or classroom and give each teacher a reasonable raise."

oh, how i wish your dear friend was our districts superintendent!


kennywilson 04/01/2010 09:31 AM

Perhaps since the board members seem to take actions that cost the district so much money, they should be required to fill the gap the superintendent position leaves open.....then maybe they would think twice about acting like school children.


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 01:00 PM in reply to kennywilson

good gracious, do you hate us? please dont wish that upon us!


zeke199 04/01/2010 01:08 PM in reply to kennywilson

NO!! We'd go from real bad to really worse!!


dmsoccerfan 04/01/2010 09:39 AM

This comment was flagged for review.


olc 04/01/2010 10:05 AM in reply to dmsoccerfan

That's not the issue. The question is what did she not do that she was supposed to to. How did she not perform her duties under the contract? Unless they can show that she somehow failed to do something substantial that was contractually obligated, it's going to cost them a bundle, just like the last time they had one of their power plays.


dmsoccerfan 04/01/2010 11:38 AM in reply to olc

Personally I agree with you -- the board needs to be able to justify, in court, that they had a solid reason for firing McClain -- otherwise, it will cost the district hundreds of thousands.

I'm asking another question -- which is "What has McClain accomplished during her tenure". No one has really answered that question......it's just emotion and anger and the financial implications of a firing that may not stand up to a court challenge.

Again, I ask, Did McClain do anything to justify her nearly $200000 salary for the past year and a half? Please be specific.


olc 04/01/2010 02:06 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

She doesn't need to justify what she did as long as it doesn't violate the contract. If they didn't think she was accomplishing enough beyond that, they can wait out the contract or negotiate ending the contract. That's how it's done.


zeke199 04/01/2010 12:36 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

I've been to more board meetings than I cared to attend. It's like watching a train wreck in slow motion, the sad fact is my kids and I are on the train as it crashes. The three-member voting block don't care if they derail the train, as long as they hold the power to do it.

Anyone who has spent time at these meetings KNOWS the majority of the board has tried to fire McClain for much of her two-year tenure. She was inundated with busywork which detracted from her time to do what she was hired to do. The board sat back, spun her around, criticized her when she couldn't keep all their plates spinning, and spat her out like grissle.

Now we taxpayers must cover the costs of their recklessness. I hope the board finds a way to do it without sticking it to us. Maybe they should pay for it since they had the problem working with McClain!


zeke199 04/01/2010 12:55 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

Most of the DMUSD board is in over their heads and ill-equipped to manage the district, yet won't acknowledge it. It appears most (not all) of the members lack the basic people skills to properly manage talented professionals (note two Superintendents were fired in two years).

By firing McClain yesterday the board obliterated $500K + from an already troubled financial situation (per board member White's recent statement).

The only people who will benefit are the lawyers who will descend like vultures into DMUSD's coffers. The children will lose out big time! DMUSD's mission has been failed by the board so THEY should be fired for breach of fiduciary duty!

McClain brought what the district needed - a hands-on leader who invested in the teachers and students. The board should have realized this and adjusted for whatever logistics and operations skills they thought she lacked.


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 01:04 PM in reply to dmsoccerfan

what exactly are you looking for?

the superintendents job, plain and simple, is to run the school district. she makes sure that the district strives for excellence. period. and under her leadership the district continued to be excellent. the API scores are phenomenal. despite cutbacks, kids had access to a stellar education.

Its not the role of the superintendent to go out there and make reforms or set policy. setting policy IS THE JOB OF THE BOARD. it was mcclain's job to ensure it was carried out.


sdnatv 04/01/2010 11:08 AM

November can't come soon enough. The sooner the Carmel Valley/Del Mar community can exercise a right/civic duty many forgot or simply neglected to use in 2006, the sooner this district can begin to actually move forward...something it hasn't done in a very long time.


sandiegovoice 04/01/2010 12:20 PM

Sound like the real housecleaning job here is to get rid of these three board members. Boardmembers, if you are reading this, I suggest you start looking for another job.


Statistic 04/01/2010 02:45 PM

She must be the only public employee fired since... since... time began.


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 03:26 PM in reply to Statistic

no, no... that would be Tom Bishop. Our OTHER superintendent.


say what? 04/01/2010 02:57 PM

The sad thing is, this Board has been such a joke that even if she has been rightfully fired no one trusts this to be so. They have lost respectability in our district.


cv33 04/01/2010 04:51 PM

It's interesting to compare the Solana Beach and Del Mar school districts. Both have a similar demographic make-up and are side by side geographically. Solana Beach is actually run very smoothly and efficiently. Del Mar seems to be run by a bunch of clowns. This firing is only one of several major self-inflicted problems they have. They have too many schools (some half empty), the union is too strong and overpaid, the foundation seems in place only to provide a job for the fundraiser, etc.

What's interesting is that they are essentially equal in terms of student performance. To me this says that the most important element in student performance is the quality and engagement of the parents, which is very high in both of these districts.


DMUSDparent 04/01/2010 09:21 PM in reply to cv33

i dont think our teachers are overpaid. their salary and benefits package ranks only 19th of the 39 county districts, behind solana beach and even chula vista. and yet our APIs are top notch, even a bit higher than SB (which isnt saying much, since both districts are stellar from the school report card standpoint).

cant disagree with your point about the quality of the board, however.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Del Mar school district power play in progress

Source: Union Tribune
Chris Reed
Monday, March 15, 2010

I've been forwarded materials in recent weeks that suggest that Del Mar Union School District Superintendent Sharon McClain is pressuring her school board members to go along with a huge spike in her pension by reclassifying the $16k she gets annually for retirement contributions as pay.

The California State Teachers Retirement System frowns on this sort of late-career shenanigans and has apparently told the district its decision to provide the spike last June was not OK -- but McClain keeps pushing the board to pursue the matter.

My e-mails to board President Comischell Rodriguez have yielded bland or misleading responses. Is she going to go along with McClain's wish that the district push to get CalSTRS to change its mind? Or will she try to defy CalSTRS and deem McClain's pension to be much higher?

Will she OK using school district-paid attorneys to try to get CalSTRS to change its mind?

Keep in mind that McClain's pension is already going to be well north of six figures. And CalSTRS is woefully underfunded with about $40 billion less in its portfolio then what it is obligated to pay out. This looks like an ugly, inappropriate, costly power play to me.

So what will Rodriguez and the rest of the board do?

We'll see.

But remember what happened in San Ysidro. This is from the April 27, 2006, U-T:

Judge rejects higher pensions for 2 former school officials

SAN YSIDRO -- The $15,000 raises two San Ysidro school administrators got just weeks before their retirement in 2002 do not qualify them for higher publicly funded pensions, an administrative law judge has ruled.

The judge agreed with retirement system auditors who found that the San Ysidro school board gave the raises to boost the pensions of former assistant superintendents Christine Aranda and Alice De La Torre. That is an illegal practice known as spiking.

Aranda and De La Torre requested a hearing, which was in September, to challenge the audit by the California State Teachers' Retirement System. ...

In 2004, CalSTRS put a stop to the higher retirement payments and put Aranda and De La Torre on installment plans to repay the surplus pension money they had received. Neither they nor the San Ysidro School District face additional sanctions. ...

CalSTRS did not dispute the legality of the raises. It found only that those raises should not be used in calculating retirement benefits. ...

The case began in June 2002. It was then that the board increased the salaries of Aranda and De La Torre from $104,494 to $120,000 a year, retroactive to the previous July. ...

The current San Ysidro board spent $72,000 in legal fees on the case before dropping its opposition to the CalSTRS findings. Aranda and De La Torre then hired their own attorney to represent them in a hearing in September.

If McClain wants to pursue this with CalSTRS, she shoud do it on her own dime.

As for Del Mar school board members, it's time they grew spines.

More information:

Thursday, August 21, 2008

Del Mar hires new head of schools

Educator worked in Hermosa Beach

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20080821-9999-1mc21mcclain.html

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

August 21, 2008

Del Mar school trustees last night unanimously voted to hire the head of the Hermosa Beach City School District as superintendent.

Sharon McClain beat out 20 other candidates from around the nation.

Trustee Janet Lamborghini called McClain “an exemplary educator” and “great collaborator” whose love for music and languages will fit well in Del Mar.

“She is a great match for this district because of her interests, because of her energy, because of her consensus building,” Lamborghini said. “I could go on and on.”

Board President Annette Easton said McClain was an extremely likable person who reaches out to community members and makes a point of eating lunch with children in her district. “Her personality is going to be just a great fit,” Easton said.

McClain will visit schools on the first day of school on Monday, but she is expected to shuttle between Hermosa Beach and Del Mar for a few weeks so she can conclude business up north, Easton said.

The details of her contract are still being worked out, and trustees are expected to vote on the agreement within the next two weeks, Easton said.

McClain last night said she was thrilled with the board's decision. “I really am happy,” she said. “Del Mar is such a wonderful school district.” McClain called Del Mar a “beautiful community” with strong parent involvement and “a great staff” among teachers, administrators and other school employees.

McClain, an educator for 30 years, has worked as an elementary school teacher, principal, assistant superintendent and superintendent.

She is a graduate of San Diego State University, where she majored in Spanish, and the University of La Verne, where she earned her doctorate in education.

Her husband, Joe Condon, is superintendent of the Lawndale Elementary School District near Los Angeles International Airport.

McClain and her husband have six children, all grown.

McClain's district in Hermosa Beach is among the highest performing in California, with an Academic Performance Index – the state's key measure of overall school performance – of 905 in 2007. Del Mar Union had a higher API score in 2007 – 947 – and with about 3,800 students, it's more than three times bigger than the district in Hermosa Beach.

Del Mar school trustees were particularly impressed by McClain's efforts to introduce foreign languages to elementary school students. McClain established a Spanish language program in Hermosa Beach and also launched a program in Mandarin.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Del Mar Union trustees to hire superintendent

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20080820-0734-1bo20sup.html
7:34 a.m. August 20, 2008

DEL MAR: Del Mar Union School District trustees are expected to hire the head of the Hermosa Beach City School District as superintendent this evening, after a six-month search.

Sharon McClain, an educator for more than 30 years, is expected to be hired by trustees at a special board meeting at 5 p.m. at Ashley Falls School, 13030 Ashley Falls Drive in Carmel Valley.

Twenty-one people applied for the Del Mar superintendent position, and the board narrowed the field to six finalists, said Ken Noonan, whose firm, The Cosca Group, conducted the search. The board was eager to hire someone before the start of the school year on Monday.

“I think it's a very good match,” said Noonan, a trustee for the state Board of Education and the former superintendent of the Oceanside Unified School District.

“I hope I can come to Del Mar,” McClain said. “It's a wonderful school district . . . with great teachers and staff.”

The Hermosa Beach district, which enrolls about 1,100 students in kindergarten through sixth grade, is smaller than Del Mar Union, which enrolls about 3,800. Under McClain's leadership, the Hermosa Beach district is one of the top performing districts in the state.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Del Mar school district expected to name superintendent Wednesday

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20080819-1923-bn19supe.html.

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

7:23 p.m. August 19, 2008

DEL MAR – The superintendent of the Hermosa Beach City School District is expected to be hired as head of the Del Mar Union School District at a board of trustees meeting Wednesday evening.

Sharon McClain, an educator for more than 30 years, was chosen as the top contender out of 21 applicants, Ken Noonan, whose firm The Cosca Group conducted the search, confirmed Tuesday afternoon.

McClain, contacted in Hermosa Beach, said she was thrilled at the possibility of coming to Del Mar.

“It's a beautiful community, with great teachers and staff,” she said. “It's heaven in terms of school districts.”

The Del Mar school board is scheduled to vote to hire McClain at a special meeting at 5 p.m. Wednesday. The meeting will be at Ashley Falls School, 13030 Ashley Falls Drive in Carmel Valley.

Del Mar Union has been without a permanent superintendent since late February, when a fractured school board ousted Tom Bishop, who had a 10-year tenure. Trustees Annette Easton, Katherine White and Steve McDowell, who have formed a consistent voting bloc on the board, had criticized Bishop for running the district with what they said was a heavy hand.

Former Trustee Linda Crawford, who resigned from the board in mid-March, and Trustee Janet Lamborghini, who is not running for re-election this fall, supported Bishop but made up a board minority.

The Del Mar school board is scheduled to spend most of the day Wednesday visiting McClain's school district in Hermosa Beach, which enrolls about 1,100 students and is one of the top-performing in the state. Its Academic Performance Index, a state measure of academic performance, was 905 in 2007 – compared with Del Mar Union's score of 947. Both are considered among the best in California.

Del Mar Union, with about 3,800 students, is more than three times larger than the district in Hermosa Beach.

The Del Mar board was eager to hire someone by the start of school on Monday, and trustees worked especially hard in recent weeks to comb through a group of finalists, Noonan said.

“Our company's goal was to present a very difficult decision to make,” he said. “The candidates were superb, so it was not easy for them to choose.”

White would not confirm that the board was considering McClain, and she declined to say anything about the search until Wednesday.

“We haven't made any announcements about anything,” White said. “We obviously have not taken a vote. Otherwise, we would have had to announce it.”

Lamborghini and Easton also said they couldn't comment. Trustees Steve McDowell and Doug Perkins could not be reached Tuesday evening.

Noonan said the board was particularly impressed by McClain's dedication to exposing elementary school students to foreign languages. In Hermosa Beach, she championed a program to teach students Spanish in a district where few are native Spanish speakers. She also has worked to establish a foreign language program in Mandarin, and she has traveled to China to research language programs there, Noonan said.

McClain majored in Spanish as an undergraduate at San Diego State University, and for a time she studied in Guadalajara, Mexico, and in San Antonio de Belen in Costa Rica.

She completed her master's degree at National University and received her doctorate from the University of La Verne.

Over the years, McClain has worked as a teacher, principal, assistant superintendent and superintendent.

Her husband, Joe Condon, is superintendent of the Lawndale Elementary School District, near Los Angeles International Airport.

The couple are the parents of six children, including four foster children. All are grown.

McClain has worked as a vocal teacher, and she plays the violin and piano – pluses for the school district in Del Mar, whose parents have supported arts education.

The board is still negotiating McClain's salary and benefits, Noonan said Tuesday afternoon. Tom Bishop's salary was about $192,000 annually when he left.

Bruce Lieberman: (760) 476-8205; bruce.lieberman@uniontrib.com.

More information:

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Clock ticking on open space

Group owes $3.5 million on land preserved for city

By Monica Unhold

http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20080614-9999-1mc14shores.html

June 14, 2008

DEL MAR – After banding together to secure the last piece of open space in Del Mar before it was snapped up by developers, members of the Campaign for Del Mar Shores are left with a large debt and limited time to pay it off.

The site is prime real estate in the heart of Del Mar – 5.3 acres of ocean-view property at Ninth Street and Camino del Mar, the city's main street.

The community group spent three years raising $5 million to buy the land to give to the city. It now has 11 months to raise the remaining $3.5 million in the $8.5 million sale that became final last month.

The city has guaranteed that the group will come up with the balance to pay the seller, the Del Mar Union School District.

“We're very optimistic that we'll be able to raise the remaining funds,” campaign chairman Joe Sullivan said this week.

The group must pay off the balance in monthly installments of $500,000, with 5 percent interest, between November and May 2009 or the school district can sell the property to someone else.

The playing fields at the site, which is called the Del Mar Shores property for an elementary school that closed there in 1970, are a major reason the community rallied to save the land from developers.

Kim Filanc, a 20-year resident of Del Mar, is particularly attached to the property because her son and daughter spent a lot of time there as children.

Her daughter attended a preschool that once operated there and her son played baseball on the field. Although she does not go to the park as often anymore, she donated $25,000 to help it remain open for public use for a long time to come, she said.

“It's just nice to know it's there,” Filanc said.

Some of the buildings on the site are used by the school district for administrative offices, and the rest by the private Winston School.

The Winston School, which has occupied part of the site for 20 years and enrolls children with special learning needs, has promised to raise 35 percent to 50 percent of the property's purchase price. In return, the school has signed a long-term lease to remain on the city-owned property.

On June 1, Campaign for Del Mar Shores held a community barbecue to celebrate the May 19 closing of escrow. The campaign invited the 300 people who attended to suggest how the land should be used.

While the suggestions have not yet been formally compiled, Sullivan said they mostly revolved around recreational uses such as improving the playground, installing picnic benches and adding an outdoor fitness course.

Members of an informal dog group that meets on the grounds in the afternoons suggested adding an enclosed dog park area, Sullivan said. A larger baseball field and community garden were suggested. Although the community had the opportunity to make suggestions, the City Council has no immediate plans to put the use of the park on its agenda, Councilwoman Crystal Crawford said.

For now, the priority is to help fundraising efforts to pay off the $3.5 million owed to the school district, she said.

The group has until Nov. 15 to raise the first $500,000 payment. Nearly 225 people have donated to the campaign, with contributions of up to $1 million coming from some individuals.

To raise the additional money, the group plans to hold neighborhood coffees, campaign coordinator Barbara Mandel Pache said. The group may also apply for private grants.

If every adult in Del Mar donated $1,000 to the park, the $3.5 million would be paid off, Pache said. While that goal may seem absurd in some places, it may not be in Del Mar, where the median household income is about $113,000.

Sullivan said fundraising was remarkably successful when there was no guarantee the purchase would happen.

“People were very generous in donating on the promise and hope of acquiring the property,” he said.

The Del Mar Shores land has long been connected to service to the community. In the late 1800s, it was the original location of the Del Mar train station. From 1947 to 1970, it was the site of Del Mar Shores School. Eventually the student population outgrew the facilities. Students were diverted to new campuses, and the school was closed.


Monica Unhold is a Union-Tribune intern.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

School board fills empty trustee seat

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/education/20080510-9999-1mc10delmar.html

May 10, 2008

DEL MAR – Trustees of the Del Mar Union School District late Wednesday unanimously approved the appointment of Doug Perkins, a longtime resident, to the school board.

Perkins, who runs a public relations and consulting firm in San Diego, will serve out the term of Linda Crawford. Crawford resigned this spring, citing irreconcilable differences with trustees Katherine White, Annette Easton and Steven McDowell.

The three trustees have formed a political majority on the board, and earlier this spring they voted to buy out the contract of former Superintendent Tom Bishop. Crawford and trustee Janet Lamborghini opposed the ouster.

Perkins, 57, is a district parent with three children in elementary, middle and high schools. He said Thursday that he will work hard to be a consensus builder among parents, teachers and others.

“I'm a big believer in public involvement,” he said.

Perkins said he intends to run for election in November to continue serving as a trustee. He said he looks forward to helping find a superintendent to replace Bishop.

“I've been interested in education for a long time, and thought it would be a great opportunity,” Perkins said.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

School board to pick trustee's replacement

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/education/20080327-9999-1m27delmar.html

By Helen Gao
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

March 27, 2008

The Del Mar school board will appoint a replacement for Linda Crawford instead of holding an election. Crawford resigned earlier this month.

The Del Mar Union School District board yesterday approved procedures and a timeline for the appointment to be made May 7 at a public meeting at which applicants will each have five minutes to speak. The meeting will be at Ocean Air School, 11444 Canter Heights Drive. Applicants will start addressing the board at 3:15 p.m.

The district will advertise the vacancy in newspapers between Tuesday and April 15. Application packets will be available Tuesday on the district's Web site at www.dmusd.org and at district offices, 225 Ninth St.

Applications are due by 3 p.m. April 25 by fax, mail or delivery to the district's offices. Applications are public records and will be available for review.

Crawford was one of two trustees who voted Feb. 26 against buying out Superintendent Tom Bishop's contract. The board approved the buyout with a 3-2 vote.

Crawford resigned March 12. Her term expires in November, and her replacement will serve until then.

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

U-T: Del Mar school board trustee Crawford resigns

She says district is micromanaged

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20080311-1925-bn11resign.html

7:25 p.m. March 11, 2008

DEL MAR – Two weeks after a divided Del Mar school board voted 3-2 to buy out Superintendent Tom Bishop's contract in exchange for his resignation, Trustee Linda Crawford announced that she too will resign effective Wednesday.

In a telephone interview Tuesday afternoon, Crawford said trustees Annette Easton, Katherine White and Steve McDowell are micro-managing the Del Mar Union School District and not respecting the professional judgment of administrators and other professionals.

Crawford and Trustee Janet Lamborghini had voted against accepting Bishop's resignation on Feb. 26.

“We have slowed down the wheels to a crawl now, because the board asks for more and more information for the next meeting and no decisions ever get made,” Crawford said. “Maybe it's because of their inexperience on the board, not understanding how it works.”

Morale among district staff has been deteriorating because of the board's micro-managing, said Crawford, whose term was scheduled to expire this fall.

“District employees are very disheartened right now, in terms of how board members are treating them,” she said.

White said she and Crawford have had their disagreements, but they have both had the best of intentions for overseeing the school district.

“She's entitled to her opinion,” White said of Crawford's criticisms of the board majority's management style.

“Part of a school board meeting should be a dialogue and there should be questions. Otherwise, why are you pulling all those people together in a room?”

Easton, White and McDowell have formed a political majority on the board since McDowell and White were elected in November 2006. The three trustees had been highly critical of Bishop's leadership on a variety of issues. But generally, they've wanted the board to assert more control over the administration.

Lamborghini could not be reached for comment Tuesday.

On March 5, the school board appointed assistant superintendent Janet Bernard as interim superintendent while trustees look for a permanent replacement.

Jim Esterbrooks, a spokesman for the County Office of Education, said Tuesday it's not common for school board members to resign in the middle of their term. But politically divided boards can leave minority members feeling shut out.

“When a board turns over like that, when a slate gets voted in and all of a sudden someone's on the short end of a 3-2 vote, that's an instance when you do see a resignation a little more often,” Esterbrooks said.


Sunday, March 2, 2008

U-T: Wear out welcome - yet still hit pay dirt

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/jenkins/20080302-9999-1mc2jenkins.html

UNION-TRIBUNE
March 2, 2008

If I must die someday - and empirical evidence suggests it's highly likely - I want to come back to life as an embattled school superintendent.

In the various jobs I've held, getting sideways with the boss has always been a bad, if not devastating, prospect.

From what I've observed, losing your job for cause can seriously compromise your chances of a financially secure life.

Not so in the upper echelons of education. In this rarefied atmosphere, getting fired can be a really good thing.

Built into a typical superintendent's contract is the explicit understanding that parting, even under openly hostile terms, will be sour sorrow for taxpayers but a sweet payoff to the departing Mr. Chips.

Consider Tom Bishop, the 10-year superintendent of Del Mar Union School District.

After overseeing a successful era of expansion, Bishop in recent years developed into a divisive lightning rod. Critics considered him impulsive and high-handed. Flash points such as boundary changes and the attempted sale of school land in downtown Del Mar proved his undoing, observers say.

Loyalists, on the other hand, many of them teachers, thought he supervised on water.

In the 2006 election, the board changed majorities. Bishop's days were clearly numbered. Last week, during an emotional meeting, many of his supporters vented their grief.

To no avail. Bishop was let go with a promise to pay him $300,000, or roughly 18 months' pay plus perks.

Bishop's pro forma settlement parallels the 2006 deal enjoyed by former San Marcos Unified Superintendent Ed Brand, who alienated his board after one year but collected $400,000 in walking-away money.

In this circle, getting fired sure beats working.

Fortunately, Del Mar has money to burn. Five mil's in the bank. The district's aggressive foundation fills gaps.

In the post-Bishop era, Del Mar students are going to be fine. Their advantages in life aren't going anywhere. They'll continue to whale on standardized tests because, well, because they're generally from affluent families.

As most educators will concede, good scores reflect bank accounts more than anything else.

For teachers, however, the keening for Bishop will persist. He was their champion when it came to high salaries and reduced teaching hours. They, in turn, were his loyal base of support.

No wonder many Del Mar teachers showed up to tear their hair and rend their clothes when the board voted to get rid of him.

But to be honest, they were crying for themselves, not for Bishop, who was floating into the Del Mar sunset on a golden-air balloon. All around North County, teachers are facing layoffs. Their deals won't be so good.

Aside from the money, what I admire most about superintendent severance deals is the psychologically reassuring promise that no one involved will ever say anything bad about anyone else. Trustees are doling out our money, mind you, but they just can't divulge those devilish details.

Lawyers call this outbreak of genteel manners the "nondisparagement clause."

Here's how it works: Everyone agrees to throw pixie dust over the whole nasty episode. After throwing daggers at each other for months, the players are magically transformed into mute Stepford trustees.

You saw it in San Marcos, where board members smiled through their teeth and refused to explain why Brand, formerly the super of Sweetwater, was let go after a year.

Aside from the dollars and the pixie dust, there's another reason not to weep 'n' wail for Bishop.

If he doesn't want to retire, Bishop, 58, can probably find a job at another district while savoring the infusion of Del Mar dollars.

After the expansion (and affluence-driven academic success) he's overseen, his stock is no doubt high. He'll have a Google record trailing behind him, of course, but self-confident boards will be impressed with his record of achievement. Chances are, Bishop will negotiate an even higher starting salary.

You have to love it.

Superintendents wear out their welcome - and hit pay dirt.

Setting a ridiculously high bar in this rewarding end game is MiraCosta College's former President Victoria Muñoz Richart.

Richart helped make a mess of things during the infamous Palmgate scandal and then, in exchange for leaving campus, demanded (and received!) $1.6 million, $650,000 of it in punitive damages.

On Friday, Richart endured the indignity of a deposition in a citizen's lawsuit attempting to recoup a portion of that over-the-top walking-away money.

If there's any justice, Richart may wind up wishing she'd played by the same lavish, but perfectly legal, rules Bishop and Brand did.


Thursday, February 28, 2008

U-T: Schools chief looks back on his tenure

Board voted Tuesday to buy out contract

Source: http://signonsandiego.com/news/education/20080228-9999-1mc28bishop.html

By Bruce Lieberman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

February 28, 2008

DEL MAR – Tom Bishop, the departing schools chief for the Del Mar Union School District, began yesterday to sift through a decade of work and memories after the school board voted 3-2 on Tuesday to buy out his contract.


Tom Bishop

The outgoing superintendent will leave the district on vacation this Friday and officially resign April 30.

Yesterday, he said he would not criticize the school board's decision. But he said that he probably would have stayed if a majority of trustees wanted him there and that he had no other reasons for wanting to quit.

“The board that hired you is not always the board you have when you leave,” Bishop said. “It doesn't always work well, and my departure is an example of that.”

Bishop, 58, said he was proud of his role in leading the district through a decade of remarkable growth, when the number of schools grew from three to eight and the teaching staff increased from 70 to 250. The district now enrolls about 3,800 students in kindergarten through sixth grade.

“The facilities are top-rate, and especially what goes on in the classrooms is top-rate,” he said.

Bishop will leave the district with a healthy $5 million reserve, equal to 14 percent of the budget. The state requires school districts to keep a 3 percent reserve.

He said yesterday that he hopes trustees use the money to weather the state budget crisis, which is expected to cause a $1 million shortfall in Del Mar Union in 2008-09.

California districts without Del Mar's financial cushion are considering layoffs and program cuts to make ends meet.

On Tuesday night, a divided school board voted to buy out Bishop's contract, which will cost at least $287,000 and likely more than $300,000. Trustees Annette Easton, Katherine White and Steve McDowell, who voted for the buyout, have commanded a political majority on the board since late 2006. They had long criticized Bishop for wielding too much power and not listening to parents.

Bishop's critics have said the superintendent angered parents during school attendance boundary changes in 2002, had formed too close a relationship between the district and its independent parent-run nonprofit foundation, and had not been open enough concerning the sale of the Del Mar Shores school property. It's now in escrow with the city.

Some parents have been angered by district talks to start a Spanish language immersion program – a move they claim has not sufficiently involved parents.

At Tuesday's meeting, a handful of parents said it was time for a change in leadership.

But they were far outnumbered by an angry crowd of parents and teachers Tuesday, some of whom called the buyout a waste of money at a time when the district may ask parents to help offset budget cuts.

“I'm going to have to dig very deep to get the motivation to run that campaign when our school board is willing to throw away hundreds of thousands of dollars on this resignation agreement,” said Janet Pecsar, a parent at Del Mar Hills Elementary School.

Trustee Janet Lamborghini, who joined Linda Crawford in voting against the buyout, said she had “unqualified confidence” in Bishop and that he delivered “one of the best educational programs in the state.”

Bishop began his career more than three decades ago teaching high school government, history and English, and he later taught English in middle school and then the fifth grade. Before coming to Del Mar in 1998, Bishop was a superintendent of the Jamul-Dulzura Union School District for 12 years.

Bishop said he has great affection for the community in Del Mar, and he praised teachers, parents, and trustees for their dedication.

He acknowledged that he upset some parents during a decade of rapid growth and dizzying change that required setting new attendance boundaries – a contentious process in any school district.

“There's no doubt that the boundary adjustment was very divisive,” Bishop said. Easton was elected to the school board during that turmoil.

The district today is settled to the point that people who buy houses have a good idea of where their children will attend school for 20 to 30 years, he said.

Bishop said he has also set high academic expectations for all students. Last year, the district scored 947 on the state's Academic Performance Index, a multifaceted measure of academic achievement that ranges from 200 to 1,000. The district had the highest API score in the county in 2007, and the seventh highest in the state.

As the parent foundation continues to raise money to provide music, art, science and physical education teachers, trustees will struggle with equity issues, Bishop said.

He said he has wanted all schools to be treated equally, but some parents have wanted to donate just to their own campuses. The board allows parents to pay for up to two teaching positions at their child's school.

On Tuesday, Easton said trustees would not comment on the decision to buy out Bishop's contract.

On Friday, the board is scheduled to meet privately to discuss hiring an interim superintendent.



Source: http://signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20080308/news_lz1mc8lets.html

Focusing on Del Mar School District

I am writing to clarify statements I made that were quoted in “Schools chief looks back on his tenure” (Our North County, Feb. 28).

The article implied that I will be less motivated to financially support my district due to Superintendent Tom Bishop's forced resignation and buyout of his contract. Nothing could be further from the truth. I am overflowing with motivation to donate my time and money to my school and district. I have to look no further than my school's outstanding teachers and exceptional programs to find that motivation.

The quote that “I am going to have to dig deep to get the motivation to run such a campaign” referred to a letter-writing campaign focused on our legislators in Sacramento to fight the governor's proposed budget cuts. My next statement to the school board was that I will run that campaign, regardless of how they voted on the resignation, because I believe that I have a voice in government.

I recognize and appreciate the programs that my children enjoy at our school that are not paid for by public funds, and will continue to support those programs. While I respectfully disagree with the school board's decision, I will not let that stop me from supporting my school and district.

JANET PECSAR
Del Mar

I take issue with the newspaper's coverage of the Del Mar Union School District. Specifically, the coverage of the hot lunch proceeds that were diverted, the missing money at Del Mar Hieghts Elementary School and of the recent board meeting accepting Tom Bishop's resignation. Where, for example, were the mention of reprimands that were placed on Bishop? Where were any quotes from anyone supporting the board?

CORINNE HACKBART
Del Mar